A Reaction to Prof. Thomas P. Nass’s “Christ Has Instituted the Public Ministry to Bless the Church”

Abstract

Kenneth A. Cherney Jr.’s Reaction to Prof. Thomas P. Nass’s “Christ Has Instituted the Public Ministry to Bless the Church” (2025 WLS Symposium) reflects on why ongoing discussions between WELS and LCMS regarding the doctrine of the ministry matter. Cherney argues that the debate is not trivial, even if practical differences are minimal, because hermeneutics, the gospel, and ecclesial unity are at stake. He warns against reading contemporary concerns into historical theology and stresses sola Scriptura as setting the agenda rather than human constructs. The ministry exists for the sake of faith (AC V), and ministers are gifts from Christ (Eph. 4:11–13), so the doctrine should be treated in the spirit of the gospel, not as a rigid system. Cherney suggests that differing articulations of essentially the same doctrine need not divide fellowship if approached with humility and respect. He highlights Nass’s observation that denunciations of opposing views often come from one side and cautions against calcified positions. Practical reflections include the unique comprehensiveness of the parish pastorate, the implications of broadening the term “pastor,” and the meaning of a “pastoral heart” in various ministries. Cherney concludes by urging dialogue marked by charity, clarity, and shared commitment to Scripture. Abstract prepared by Microsoft Copilot (GPT‑4).