Scouting: Are Our Objections Still Valid?

Abstract

In this 1986 essay, Pastor Bruce H. Becker examines the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod’s (WELS) longstanding objections to Scouting, particularly the Boy Scouts of America, in light of updated materials and evolving practices. Becker outlines eight theological concerns—ranging from the Scouts’ treatment of Scripture and the nature of God to their emphasis on good works and religious unionism—and evaluates whether these objections remain valid. Drawing on current Scout literature, Becker concludes that despite some changes in wording and emphasis, the core principles of Scouting still conflict with biblical doctrine, especially regarding the Triune God, salvation through Christ, and the role of good works. He also discusses recent controversies, such as the Scouts’ stance on belief in a “Supreme Being,” and offers pastoral advice on addressing the Scout question with clarity and compassion. The essay affirms that WELS objections to Scouting remain theologically sound. Abstract generated by Microsoft Copilot (GPT-4)